Yes I'm still alive and well but with my schedule filled with various school projects and going to work I haven't been blogging lately. Due to recent experiences at work however I thought I'd let you in on some insider information regarding an unfortunate choice most companies have made for their email solutions.
Most people should think of MS Outlook, Thunderbird or other decent email applications before even considering Lotus Notes as a solution to their email needs.
I myself have chosen to the GMail route for personal use since I find the interface is great, although not the most efficient at times, grouping your conversations together and generally responding quickly to user actions.
But let's get back to Lotus Notes, and why I hope nobody ever has to use this horribly bloated mess of an application whose user-interface experts must have been away on vacation during its development.
First of all, the WHY.
Why would anyone even bother with it? Well, in my case the company I work at uses it so I don't have a choice. I can't think of any other reason anyone would subject themselves to its psychological torture.
Why am I bothered by it so much?
Usability Blunder #1I write an email and send it off - let's say I included a 10mb project document and sent it to Joe Swanson, Ubergenius. I also sent carbon copies (for those of you who haven't figured out what "Cc" means) to my project team.
Joe responded to my message (also using Notes) and has unfortunately selected the Reply-To-All-With-History option.
Silly, Joe. Will he ever learn?
There's a multitude of reply options in the wondertool that is Lotus Notes:
- Reply will not include any history at all
- Reply-with-History resolves that but includes all original attachments in the reply. Why anyone would want to do this on a regular basis is beyond me.
- Reply-without-Attachments is available yes, but since it's the last option on the menu it seldom gets noticed nevermind selected.
And yes, those options are duplicated for the dreaded Reply-To-All feature.
So the attachment I sent Joe has now been sent back to me as well as the 15 people in the Cc list.
Thanks, Joe for assassinating the mailbox storage limit for my whole project team.
Usability Blunder #2Respond to an item in your "sent Items" and Notes cleverly decides that the recipient should be none other than yourself: the initial sender of the message.
SURELY if you want to reply to any email you want to reply to the sender, right? Sheesh, even Gmail got this one right and it hasn't been around for long at all. I can just imagine how many years this application has butchered such a simple function.
Usability Blunder #3 Lotus Notes has a side bar on the left side of the screen that can hold your bookmarks to address books and other databases (everything in Notes is basically a database).
I can't be positive, but most people would think if you have a bookmark set to point to a certain database that's most likely what you expect it to run when you click on it.
Well folks, in the world of Notes it's a different world. Of course it will work when you initially set it up, but there have been countless times where that very bookmark that I've clicked on about 40 times this morning to run my database development project now decides to point to another database.
Hmmm ok. Well maybe the design is the same? No, it's a completely different filename in a completely different location with a completely different design.
Let's try directly opening the file I was working on before then, that should work.
Oh, it doesn't. Well it does in a way, but unfortunately I'm not satisfied with running a backup version of the database that I made about 3 weeks ago. I'd rather run the one that I've put about 50 hours of work into since, thank you.
I don't change a thing, and get back from a much needed coffee run.
Clicking on the icon now points to the proper database again.
Magic!
Usability Blunder #4Wow, the storage limit of my mailbox is really getting up there.
Around the time I get a warning before sending any outgoing mail out is when I start going through my existing items and saving/removing attachments I didn't have a chance to do at the time.
Oh here we go, I found an email with a 6mb attachment - that's probably a good chunk of memory I can restore in my profile.
I open it up, save and delete the attachment and have a look at the buttons available to me in the toolbar.
Hmmm that's weird. So I'll have to send the message back to the people in the Cc list simply because I wanted to remove the attachment? That doesn't make much sense.
To conquer this you'll need to press the Esc key which brings up a menu to "Save Only" the email without sending it to anyone. Shouldn't this be placed in the toolbar as a standard action? You'd think so... but no.
Usability Blunder #5: Developing applications using Notes DesignerLotus Notes uses the Domino server to run its databases, which use framesets, agents, forms and pages using Lotusscript, a formula language and JavaScript.
Since I'm not too familiar with JavaScript I've been using Lotusscript heavily as well as the formula language for when it's more efficient to do so (fairly often actually).
Lotusscript itself is a spin-off of visual basic... no semicolons are needed at the end of lines and the function names are pretty much identical. It has the same basic form elements such as text boxes, list- and combo-boxes and in general everything works fairly well.
The BlunderLet's say I'm in the middle of writing code for a button. I finish a line that requires some testing, the designer doesn't have a problem with the syntax so I preview my form with the code changes to ensure it works the way I expect.
Notes: "Do you want to save your form before proceeding?"I sure do! I click YES. Maybe the first time it doesn't work because I made some type of logical error in the code.
I'll exit from the preview, change the code and hit CTRL+S to save so as to not be bothered by the save-prompt again. I click Preview again.
Notes continues into preview mode, yet somehow, basic unrelated functionality in that button code that was working not 2 minutes ago is now not performing its usual action.
That's odd, let's investigate.
Found it!
A line of code that I haven't been anywhere near in the last 2 days has somehow disappeared.Once again... magic!
I've found one way to try and overcome this is clicking on the form itself after modifying the code and then doing the CTRL+S. It seems as though even using that shortcut
while in the code-editing window will give you a greater chance of code disappearance.
This is by far the most frustrating thing in the development environment.
honorable Mention: Rich Text FieldsAnother frustrating thing is probably working with rich-text fields, as for some reason after any changes are made, the document being modified must be saved, closed and re-opened in order for the changes to be seen on the screen. Amazing!
I can't think of anything else at the moment unfortunately.
As you can see, I'm far from thrilled with this application but hopefully I've steered you away for the moment until things improve.
Next up at the firing range: Motorola phonebook design.